Join CNN’s Surprise Idea science publication. Discover the universe with information on fascinating discoveries, scientific developments and extra.
CNN
—
Scientists try to unravel a decade-long thriller by figuring out the identification of anomalous alerts detected from beneath ice in Antarctica.
The unusual radio waves emerged throughout a seek for one other uncommon phenomenon: high-energy cosmic particles generally known as neutrinos. Arriving at Earth from the far reaches of the cosmos, neutrinos are sometimes known as “ghostly” as a result of they’re extraordinarily risky, or vaporous, and might undergo any type of matter with out altering.
Over the previous decade, researchers have performed a number of experiments utilizing huge expanses of water and ice which might be designed to seek for neutrinos, which might make clear mysterious cosmic rays, essentially the most extremely energetic particles within the universe. Certainly one of these initiatives was NASA’s Antarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna, or ANITA, experiment, which flew balloons carrying devices above Antarctica between 2006 and 2016.
It was throughout this hunt that ANITA picked up anomalous radio waves that didn’t appear to be neutrinos.
The alerts got here from beneath the horizon, suggesting that they had handed via 1000’s of miles of rock earlier than reaching the detector. However the radio waves ought to have been absorbed by the rock. The ANITA crew believed these anomalous alerts couldn’t be defined by the present understanding of particle physics.
Comply with-up observations and analyses with different devices, together with one just lately performed by the Pierre Auger Observatory in Argentina, haven’t been capable of finding the identical alerts. The outcomes of the Pierre Auger Collaboration have been revealed within the journal Bodily Evaluate Letters in March.
The origin of the anomalous alerts stays unclear, mentioned research coauthor Stephanie Wissel, affiliate professor of physics, astronomy and astrophysics on the Pennsylvania State College.
“Our new research signifies that such (alerts) haven’t been seen by an experiment … just like the Pierre Auger Observatory,” Wissel mentioned. “So, it doesn’t point out that there’s new physics, however moderately extra info so as to add to the story.”
Bigger, extra delicate detectors could possibly clear up the thriller, or finally show whether or not the anomalous alerts have been a fluke, whereas persevering with the seek for enigmatic neutrinos and their sources, scientists say.
Detecting neutrinos on Earth permits researchers to hint them again to their sources, which scientists consider are primarily cosmic rays that strike our planet’s ambiance.
Probably the most extremely energetic particles within the universe, cosmic rays are made up principally of protons or atomic nuclei, and they’re unleashed throughout the universe as a result of no matter produces them is such a strong particle accelerator that it dwarfs the capabilities of the Giant Hadron Collider. Neutrinos might assist astronomers higher perceive cosmic rays and what launches them throughout the cosmos.
However neutrinos are tough to seek out as a result of they’ve nearly no mass and might cross via essentially the most excessive environments, like stars and full galaxies, unchanged. They do, nevertheless, work together with water and ice.
ANITA was designed to seek for the best vitality neutrinos within the universe, at larger energies than have but been detected, mentioned Justin Vandenbroucke, an affiliate professor of physics on the College of Wisconsin, Madison. The experiment’s radio antennae seek for a brief pulse of radio waves produced when a neutrino collides with an atom within the Antarctic ice, resulting in a bathe of lower-energy particles, he mentioned.
Throughout its flights, ANITA discovered high-energy fountains of particles coming from the ice, a type of upside-down bathe of cosmic rays. The detector can also be delicate to ultrahigh vitality cosmic rays that rain down on Earth and create a radio burst that acts like a flashlight beam of radio waves.
When ANITA watches a cosmic ray, the flashlight beam is known as a burst of radio waves one-billionth of a second lengthy that may be mapped like a wave to indicate the way it displays off the ice.
Twice of their information from ANITA flights, the experiment’s authentic crew noticed alerts arising via the ice at a a lot sharper angle than ever predicted by any fashions, making it not possible to hint the alerts to their authentic sources.
“The radio waves that we detected practically a decade in the past have been at actually steep angles, like 30 levels beneath the floor of the ice,” Wissel mentioned.
Neutrinos can journey via plenty of matter, however not all through the Earth, Vandenbroucke mentioned.
“They’re anticipated to reach from barely beneath the horizon, the place there’s not a lot Earth for them to be absorbed,” he wrote in an electronic mail. “The ANITA anomalous occasions are intriguing as a result of they seem to return from effectively beneath the horizon, so the neutrinos must journey via a lot of the Earth. This isn’t potential in keeping with the Normal Mannequin of particle physics.”
The Pierre Auger Collaboration, which incorporates lots of of scientists around the globe, analyzed greater than a decade’s price of knowledge to attempt to perceive the anomalous alerts detected by ANITA.
The crew additionally used their observatory to attempt to discover the identical alerts. The Auger Observatory is a hybrid detector that makes use of two strategies to seek out and research cosmic rays. One technique depends on discovering high-energy particles as they work together with water in tanks on Earth’s floor, and the opposite tracks potential interactions with ultraviolet mild excessive in our planet’s ambiance.
“The Auger Observatory makes use of a really completely different approach to look at ultrahigh vitality cosmic ray air showers, utilizing the secondary glow of charged particles as they traverse the ambiance to find out the route of the cosmic ray that initiated it,” mentioned Peter Gorham, a professor of physics on the College of Hawaii at Mānoa. “By utilizing laptop simulations of what such a bathe of particles would appear to be if it had behaved just like the ANITA anomalous occasions, they’re able to generate a type of template for related occasions after which search their information to see if something like that seems.”
Gorham, who was not concerned with the brand new analysis, designed the ANITA experiment and has performed different analysis to grasp extra concerning the anomalous alerts.
Whereas the Auger Observatory was designed to measure downward-going particle showers produced within the ambiance by ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays, the crew redesigned their information evaluation to seek for upward-going air showers, Vandenbroucke mentioned. Vandenbroucke didn’t work on the brand new research, however he peer-reviewed it previous to publication.
“Auger has an infinite accumulating space for such occasions, bigger than ANITA,” he mentioned. “If the ANITA anomalous occasions are produced by any particle touring via the Earth after which producing upward-going showers, then Auger ought to have detected lots of them, and it didn’t.”
A separate follow-up research utilizing the IceCube Experiment, which has sensors embedded deep within the Antarctic ice, additionally looked for the anomalous alerts.
“As a result of IceCube could be very delicate, if the ANITA anomalous occasions have been neutrinos then we’d have detected them,” wrote Vandenbroucke, who served as colead of the IceCube Neutrino Sources working group between 2019 and 2022.
“It’s an attention-grabbing downside as a result of we nonetheless don’t even have a proof for what these anomalies are, however what we do know is that they’re more than likely not representing neutrinos,” Wissel mentioned.
Oddly sufficient, a unique type of neutrino, known as a tau neutrino, is one speculation that some scientists have put forth as the reason for the anomalous alerts.
Tau neutrinos can regenerate. After they decay at excessive energies, they produce one other tau neutrino, in addition to a particle known as a tau lepton — much like an electron, however a lot heavier.
However what makes the tau neutrino state of affairs impossible is the steepness of the angle related to the sign, Wissel mentioned.
“You count on all these tau neutrinos to be very, very near the horizon, like perhaps one to 5 levels beneath the horizon,” Wissel mentioned. “These are 30 levels beneath the horizon. There’s simply an excessive amount of materials. They actually would really lose fairly a little bit of vitality and never be detectable.”
On the finish of the day, Gorham and the opposite scientists do not know what the origin of the anomalous ANITA occasions are. Thus far, no interpretations match up with the alerts, which is what retains drawing scientists again to attempt to clear up the thriller. The reply could also be in sight, nevertheless.
Wissel can also be engaged on a brand new detector, the Payload for Extremely-Excessive Vitality Observations or PUEO, that can fly over Antarctica for a month starting in December. Bigger and 10 occasions extra delicate than ANITA, PUEO might reveal extra info on what’s inflicting the anomalous alerts detected by ANITA, Wissel mentioned.
“Proper now, it’s considered one of these long-standing mysteries,” Wissel mentioned. “I’m excited that after we fly PUEO, we’ll have higher sensitivity. In precept, we should always have the ability to higher perceive these anomalies which is able to go a protracted strategy to understanding our backgrounds and finally detecting neutrinos sooner or later.”
Gorham mentioned that PUEO, an acronym that references the Hawaiian owl, ought to have the sensitivity to seize many anomalous alerts and assist scientists discover a solution.
“Typically you simply have to return to the drafting board and actually work out what this stuff are,” Wissel mentioned. “The more than likely state of affairs is that it’s some mundane physics that may be defined, however we’re form of knocking on all of the doorways to attempt to determine what these are.”
About The Author
