In June 2020, Linda Dane received shocking news regarding her long-lost brother, Gary Herbst. His skull had been discovered by a dog in a rural area of Barron County, Wisconsin, prompting a police investigation into the circumstances of his disappearance, which had begun in 2013.
### Background on Gary Herbst’s Disappearance
Gary Herbst, who was 57 when he went missing, was described by his sister as a solitary figure with a challenging personality, making it difficult for family members to keep in touch. His wife, Connie, had informed Linda that Gary had walked out on her and their teenage son, Austin, yet she had not reported his disappearance to the police. This lack of action raised suspicions for Linda, who found it puzzling that Connie had not considered filing a missing person report.
At the time Linda learned of Gary’s death, it had been several years since her family last heard from him. With Linda’s encouragement, Connie eventually filed a missing person’s report with local authorities, stating that Gary had taken a suitcase and left in an older gray Honda. Six years later, the case was reopened by investigative genetic genealogist Robin Espensen, who utilized DNA techniques to identify the remains as Gary Herbst’s.
### Uncovering the Truth
As detectives delved deeper into the investigation, they discovered that both Connie and Austin worked at a retirement community and had been surprisingly stoic upon learning about Gary’s identity. Interviews with the family revealed a backdrop of familial tension and hints of domestic abuse. Connie described Gary as a volatile individual who used drugs, contributing to a dysfunctional household. Their son, Austin, corroborated this account, detailing a history of abuse and anger directed towards his mother.
However, inconsistencies began to emerge between the narratives given by Connie and Austin. Investigators found that while Connie had claimed to be home when Gary left, her account shifted during questioning, and she eventually disclosed that a firearm had also gone missing after Gary’s departure. This raised further suspicions among law enforcement, who felt both Connie and Austin might have had some involvement in Gary’s disappearance and potential murder.
### Investigative Developments and Arrests
The investigation intensified when detectives conducted interviews and received a tip regarding suspicious behavior at the Herbst home around the time Gary went missing. Neighbors reported odd activities occurring late at night, including what appeared to be scrubbing floors and loading items into a vehicle.
Further evidence emerged when investigators obtained a search warrant for the former Herbst home, which revealed blood stains and other signs of potential foul play. A cadaver dog detected the scent of human remains, leading to a belief that Gary had likely been murdered in the house.
On November 19, 2020, both Connie and Austin were arrested and later charged with second-degree murder. As the investigation continued to unfold, Austin confessed to the fatal shooting of his father, claiming that he believed this act was necessary to protect his mother from further abuse.
### Sentencing and Community Reactions
Austin was ultimately sentenced to 12 years and six months in prison, with the judge expressing empathy for his claims of abuse while also validating the serious nature of his crime. Connie was sentenced to two years and three months but served only a fraction of that time, further igniting discussions about the justice system’s treatment of domestic violence cases.
The community response was mixed; some neighbors viewed the Herbsts’ actions as justifiable, given Gary’s alleged behavior, while others expressed concern over the lack of consequences for what they labeled as heinous acts.
### The Aftermath
As both Austin and Connie navigate their lives post-sentencing, the case remains deeply entrenched in controversy. For Linda Dane and other family members, the tragic story of Gary Herbst’s life and death continues to evoke complex emotions surrounding familial loyalty, domestic abuse, and the implications of justice in a troubled household.
As the investigation concluded, many are left to ponder the nature of justice and morality in situations steeped in family trauma.
Source: Original Reporting
About The Author
