The South Orange & Maplewood school district in New Jersey has come under scrutiny following the removal of Junot Díaz’s acclaimed novel, The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, from the curriculum of a high-level English class at Columbia High School (CHS). This decision arises amid increasing concerns regarding student mental health after a spate of attempted suicides within the student body.
Community Mental Health Crisis
Schools superintendent Jason Bing stated that at least five CHS students have attempted suicide this academic year. In December, a CHS student also died in an accident, while another known to the community took their life. This alarming trend has prompted the district to reassess its curriculum and support offerings, culminating in the decision to pull the novel, which includes themes related to suicide.
Bing explained that the removal was initiated not by parental requests but by administrators who sought to address a pressing mental health crisis among students. In a move that has been characterized as a “book ban” by advocacy group PEN America, the district subsequently offered parents an option to allow their children access to the book through a signed permission slip. This action, however, has not satiated criticism aimed at the district’s approach.
Responses from Educators and Advocates
In the aftermath of the decision, CHS students and educators expressed disappointment and concern. Lori Martling, the teacher responsible for the Advanced Placement (AP) English Literature class, underscored the literary richness and cultural significance of Oscar Wao. Originally introduced to the curriculum in 2011, the novel explores complex themes including identity, cultural conflict, and mental health struggles, particularly as they pertain to the diaspora of Dominican Republic immigrants.
Martling has shared her belief that literature can serve as a means for students to connect with their feelings and foster resilience, especially in an environment where mental health issues are becoming increasingly commonplace. The novel’s removal was first publicized by CHS student journalist Ella Levy, and sparked a petition that garnered support from over 200 students and alumni in favor of reinstating the book in the classroom.
Broader Implications of Book Bans
Supporters of literary freedom have pointed to a national trend where books exploring difficult topics related to mental health, such as grief and suicide, are being restricted in schools. Research from PEN America shows that nearly 60% of banned books in recent years have dealt with these very themes, indicating a growing aversion to addressing mental health issues in educational settings.
Kasey Meehan, a program director for PEN America’s Freedom to Read initiative, articulated concerns that the impulse to shield students from challenging content could unintentionally stifle learning and growth. While the district’s decision is rooted in a desire to protect students, critics argue that such restrictions may limit important conversations surrounding mental health.
Diverging Opinions on Literature’s Role
The school district’s stance has also been compounded by questions regarding the consistency of its policies. Students have pointed out that works such as Shakespeare’s Hamlet and Romeo and Juliet, which tackle themes of death and despair, remain in the curriculum despite the heightened sensitivity surrounding Oscar Wao. This inconsistency raises questions about a perceived bias against contemporary works addressing current societal issues.
Díaz himself has responded to the debate, asserting that art and literature play crucial roles in broadening perspectives and fostering conversations. He emphasized the importance of discussing difficult topics, stating that excluding such narratives from educational settings fails to adequately support students dealing with complex emotions and societal realities.
The Path Forward
As public outcry continues, the South Orange & Maplewood district has announced plans to offer parents the option to grant permission for their children to read Oscar Wao, although the novel’s teaching will still be subject to restrictions. The administration aims to finalize access by early March, signaling a tentative step toward reconciling educational objectives with community demands.
The episode has highlighted persistent tensions in educational environments about how best to address mental health crises while maintaining a commitment to literary freedom. For now, the discussion continues as students, educators, and administrators navigate these complex issues, and many advocates call for increased mental health resources in schools as a more effective solution to the underlying problems affecting student well-being.
If you or someone you know is struggling with suicidal thoughts, please reach out for support by calling or texting 988.
Source: Original Reporting
About The Author
