What my mother-in-law did put our youngster at severe threat. My husband blames me.

Care and Feeding is Slate’s parenting recommendation column. Have a query for Care and Feeding? Submit it right here.

Pricey Care and Feeding,

My mother-in-law, “Patricia,” is a recovering alcoholic with six years of sobriety. Not too long ago, my sister wanted me to take her and my 1-year-old nephew to an appointment along with his pediatrician (her automobile was within the store and her husband was at work). I left my 3-year-old son, “Harry,” with Patricia.

Whereas I used to be with my sister, I obtained a name from a neighbor. She had been strolling her canine when she got here throughout Harry wandering the neighborhood in tears. He informed her that “Grandma received’t get up.” She took him residence and located Patricia handed out. An almost empty Scotch bottle (which had been a present from a consumer to my husband; we don’t drink and have been planning to re-gift it) was on the ground. My neighbor known as 911, after which she known as me. Patricia needed to stay hospitalized for 2 days with alcohol poisoning.

Now my husband is blaming me for not hiding the Scotch “correctly,” provided that I do know his mom’s historical past. The bottle was in our pantry behind the cereal bins! The highest of the bottle was seen, nevertheless it wasn’t precisely conspicuous, and actually, it by no means occurred to me to “disguise” it. And whereas it’s tragic that his mom had a relapse and have become significantly ailing on account of it, it may have been much more of a tragedy for our son, outside alone on the lookout for assist, and that isn’t registering with him. Patricia has been extraordinarily apologetic, however contemplating what occurred, I don’t need her watching Harry on her personal anymore. My husband says I’m making an attempt to “punish” his mom for what occurred. So far as he’s involved, it would by no means once more be a difficulty since we don’t often maintain alcohol in the home. Am I going too far?

—A Horrible Time to Fall Off the Wagon

Pricey Horrible Time,

There’s an excessive amount of I don’t know for me to make a ruling about whether or not perpetually banning Patricia as a sitter is “going too far.” Since she was the one you turned to in a non-emergency state of affairs to sit down on your 3-year-old, I’m guessing that she has three years of reliability and trustworthiness behind her. You’re in a significantly better place than I to find out whether or not what occurred is an anomaly. (Your husband’s argument—that it received’t/can’t occur once more since you received’t have alcohol in the home sooner or later—is specious.)

The larger problem right here, I feel, is that your husband blames you for what occurred. This isn’t a wholesome or affordable response. (I believe that it’s a discovered one; that rationalizing his mother’s consuming and blaming it on others was as soon as a coping mechanism.) It’s additionally an issue that he’s now indignant with you for “punishing” his mother—as is, clearly, his failure to take significantly the jeopardy his mom put your son in.

The 2 of it’s essential cope with all this competition now. Should you can’t speak actually about what occurred with out combating (or speaking previous one another), get some assist. As to having your mother-in-law babysit, I’d give it a while. In different phrases, for now and the quick future, don’t depart your youngster together with her (you don’t have to make an enormous announcement about it; simply don’t do it). See how issues go. You may revisit this determination later.

In case your husband can’t get behind this plan, proceed the dialogue within the presence of a wedding counselor.

—Michelle

Extra Recommendation From Slate

Is there such a factor as taking too many footage of your youngsters? My husband, who is a good father, is admittedly fanatical about taking pictures of our solely youngster, a 3-year-old lady. He takes footage of her CONSTANTLY. He thinks it’s essential to doc each day, so he’ll take a minimal of 10 pictures each day, together with a couple of quick movies.